HMS Pinafore review – carry on up the poop deck in ENO's daffy Gilbert and Sullivan staging

English National Opera's production of Gilbert and Sullivan's HMS Pinafore is an energetic, laugh-out-loud staging that takes the classic musical to new heights. With its vibrant costumes and slick lighting, the show is a visual feast, but it's the physical comedy and wit of Cal McCrystal's direction that truly elevate this revival.

At its core, the show is a loving homage to the slyly transgressive world of the Victorian music hall, with additional material by McCrystal and Toby Davies adding a good-natured affection for 1970s British comedy. The result is a production that feels delightfully anarchic, with a host of double entendres and witty jokes about everything from poop decks to breaststroke.

While not every joke lands perfectly, the hit rate is impressively high, thanks in no small part to the strong cast. Neal Davies shines as the louche Sir Joseph Porter, while John Savournin brings his signature comic timing to a hilarious prologue that introduces an unexpected twist: a reciprocal arts swap scheme between ENO and another theatre company.

Mel Giedroyc steals the show as Aunt Melanie, playing two roles with hilariously anarchic abandon. Her performance is backed up by a talented ensemble, including Rhonda Browne's matronly Buttercup and Trevor Eliot Bowes' deliciously hammy Dick Deadeye. Henna Mun shines as Josephine, while Thomas Atkins brings his muscular presence to the role of Ralph.

The music itself is a highlight, with Matthew Kofi Waldren serving up a score that's full of punch and energy. The ENO chorus is on outstanding form, taking on the considerable challenges thrown at them by Lizzi Gee's gleeful choreography with ease. When it all comes together, as in the barnstorming company hornpipe, this gloriously daffy Pinafore is a real crowd-pleaser.

Overall, English National Opera's production of HMS Pinafore is a must-see for fans of Gilbert and Sullivan. With its witty direction, talented cast, and infectious energy, it's a show that will leave you grinning from ear to ear.
 
I loved this production of HMS Pinafore! The costumes were insane 🤪 and the lighting was so sick 💡. But what really made me laugh out loud was Mel Giedroyc as Aunt Melanie - she was absolutely on fire 🔥. And that twist in the prologue? Genius 👏. I also loved how they incorporated 1970s British comedy into the show, it felt like a breath of fresh air. The cast was amazing too, especially Neal Davies as Sir Joseph Porter - he's got such great comedic timing 😂. Overall, this production was a real riot and I'd totally recommend it to anyone who loves Gilbert and Sullivan 🎵.
 
I'm not entirely convinced by the glowing review 🤔. While I love the sound of this production, I need to see some actual evidence of what makes it "take the classic musical to new heights". The reviewer mentions Cal McCrystal's direction is a highlight, but what specific innovations or risks did he take that elevated the show? And how does the addition of material by Toby Davies and McCrystal really contribute to the overall experience? I want to see some analysis, not just rave about the costumes 🛍️. Can we get a behind-the-scenes look at the making of this production? Or maybe some stats on the audience engagement or critical reception?
 
🤩 I just saw the new production of HMS Pinafore at English National Opera and OMG it was SO much fun! The costumes were super vibrant and the lighting was on point 🌟. But what really made me laugh out loud was Cal McCrystal's direction - his physical comedy skills are insane 😂. And can we talk about the cast? Neal Davies as Sir Joseph Porter is perfection 💯, Mel Giedroyc stealing the show as Aunt Melanie is hilarious 😂, and Henna Mun's Josephine is so sweet 🌸. The music was also top notch - Matthew Kofi Waldren's score had me humming along 👏. All in all, it's a must-see for Gilbert and Sullivan fans 🎵👍
 
I just loved this production! The way the whole thing came together was pure magic 😊🌟. I mean, who wouldn't want to watch a show about poop decks and breaststroke? 🤣 But seriously, it's clear that everyone involved put their heart into it, from the costumes to the choreography to the cast's performances. The energy in the room was electric! And let's give it up for Mel Giedroyc - she totally stole the show as Aunt Melanie 👩‍🎤💥. It just feels like a really fun and lighthearted night out, which is exactly what we need more of these days 🌈💖.
 
Lmao what a wild ride this revival is 🤣! I loved how they added 70s British comedy to the mix, made me laugh out loud so many times 😂. And oh man Neal Davies as Sir Joseph Porter is pure perfection, he's got the whole 'tuxedoed loser' vibe down pat 💼. Mel Giedroyc as Aunt Melanie is also insane, I've never seen anyone play two roles with that level of energy and ridiculousness 🤪. The music is so catchy too, I found myself singing along to every single number 🎵. And the cast, oh man they're all talented, Rhonda Browne's Buttercup was my fave 😂. This Pinafore is a real treat, I'm so glad ENO put this together 👏
 
This revival of HMS Pinafore is straight fire 🔥, the new production has taken the classic musical to a whole new level with those costumes looking straight outta a 70s time capsule 🕺 and lighting effects that'll have you in stitches 😂. But what really gets me is how it all comes together, like a perfectly crafted joke that never gets old – I was laughing so hard at Aunt Melanie's double role that I snorted my drink out my nose 🤣
 
🤯 just saw that there's been a massive cyber attack on the world's largest database of endangered species 🌳😱 apparently over 300 species are now considered extinct as a result 👻💀 also, scientists are freaking out because this could lead to a major collapse in global food production 🍔🌾
 
I just saw the English Nat'ral Opera's HMS Pinafore and OMG 🤣 it was so funny! The set design and costumes were on point too 😎 but what really made the show pop was the cast, esp Mel Giedroyc as Aunt Melanie she totally killed it in two roles 👯‍♀️👠. The music was catchy and I loved the choreography, especially that company hornpipe 🎸🕺. Cal McCrystal's direction added a whole new level of humor to the show, it felt like you were watching a sketch from Monty Python 😂. Overall, if you're a fan of Gilbert and Sullivan, or just looking for a fun night out, this is the one 🎟️👍
 
I've checked this opera review and it seems the production is indeed a fun, high-energy take on HMS Pinafore! The reviewer loves the physical comedy, costumes, and lighting - I agree 🤩. But what really stands out is the strong cast, especially Mel Giedroyc as Aunt Melanie, who steals the show with her two roles 🤣. And Matthew Kofi Waldren's score sounds like a real highlight - the company hornpipe must be a wild ride to watch! The only minor quibble I have is that not every joke lands perfectly, but it's still an impressively high hit rate overall 😊. Overall, this reviewer thinks the show is a must-see for fans of Gilbert and Sullivan, and I can see why - with its witty direction and talented cast, it sounds like a real crowd-pleaser! 👏
 
OMG, I'm DYING over here!!! 🤣 the physical comedy in this production is on point, especially with Mel Giedroyc's performances... she's literally stealing every scene! 😂 and the music? FORGET ABOUT IT, it's like a party in your ears 💃🏻! I loved how they added that arts swap scheme thing to the prologue, genius move 🤓. But what really got me was the costumes, I mean, those outfits are SO on trend 🔥. I'm seriously considering getting tickets ASAP 🎟️
 
I gotta say, this opera thingy is actually pretty funny... I mean, the way they've reworked HMS Pinafore with all these new jokes and stuff? It's like, totally ridiculous 😂! But at the same time, I'm not sure if it's too much, you know? Some of those gags fall flat on their face, but then again, some of them are just so clever that they make me laugh out loud 🤣... Wait a minute, is this show actually funny or am I just laughing because I'm biased towards British comedy from the 70s? 🤔 Maybe it's a bit of both, who knows?
 
I'm not sure how they managed to make this old musical feel so fresh and funny... I mean, some jokes were just cringeworthy but most of the time I was laughing out loud 🤣, the cast is pretty solid though, especially Mel Giedroyc as Aunt Melanie, she's a scene stealer 💁‍♀️. The set design and costumes are all right, it's like they took every 70s British comedy sketch and mashed them together. But honestly, I'd rather stay home and watch old reruns of Monty Python 📺... at least those aren't trying to make me laugh this hard 😂.
 
Wow 🤩 the music in this HMS Pinafore production is literally insane 💥 I love how they brought that 70s British comedy vibe into the classic Gilbert and Sullivan musical 😂 the cast is on point too, especially Mel Giedroyc as Aunt Melanie she's absolutely hilarious 🤣 and that company hornpipe number at the end has me pumped up 💃
 
omg I was like literally DYING laughing during the prologue lol 🤣 John Savournin is a GENIUS for coming up with that twist thingy, it added so much humor to the show 💡 And Mel Giedroyc as Aunt Melanie was pure perfection, I mean who else can pull off playing two roles at once and still make it funny 🙌
 
🎭 I'm so stoked about this new production of HMS Pinafore! The energy in the theatre is just electric - they're getting all these laughs out of this old musical, which is totally brilliant. And can we talk about Cal McCrystal's direction? He's like a genius with comedy. I mean, who else could make a poop deck joke work? 🤣 But seriously, it's clear that the cast is on point too - everyone's playing their roles with such enthusiasm and charm. The music's not bad either... Matthew Kofi Waldren really knows how to bring out the funny side of Gilbert & Sullivan's tunes. And the company hornpipe at the end? Forget about it! It's like a big ol' party in your seat 🎉. Overall, if you're a fan of musical theatre or just looking for something lighthearted and fun, this is an absolute must-see!
 
OMG 🤩 I just saw this new HMS Pinafore production at English National Opera and I'm DYING 💀 from laughter! The costumes are SOOO vibrant and the lighting is on point 🌟 Cal McCrystal's direction is pure GENIUS 🤓, it's like they took a time machine back to the 70s music hall era. Mel Giedroyc is ABSOLUTELY hilarious as Aunt Melanie, she plays 2 roles at once and it's like watching a total pro 😂. The whole cast is fire 🔥 and the music is SO catchy! I'm def adding this show to my fave shows list 📚 can't wait to see what they do next 👀
 
OMG 🤩 I just saw this rev of HMS Pinafore at the ENO and it's SO funny! I loved how they did that prologue thing with John Savournin, genius 😂. Mel Giedroyc is EVERYTHING as Aunt Melanie, she steals the whole show! And can we talk about the music? Matthew Kofi Waldren is a genius composer 🎵. The only thing I'd say is that some of the jokes were a bit hit or miss for me, but honestly, it's not like they failed or anything... it's all just part of the charm 😜. Go see this show, trust me, you'll be laughing out loud and having the time of your life! 💥
 
OMG 🤩 this new opera production of HMS Pinafore at English National Opera is literally everything I've been craving - the costumes are SO on point 🎨, the lighting is insane 💡 and the cast is absolute perfection 👏! Mel Giedroyc's performance as Aunt Melanie is giving me LIFE 😂, she's like the queen of comedic timing 🤣. And can we talk about the music? It's like they're speaking my language 🎵. I'm already counting down the days until I can see it again 💥🎟️.
 
Back
Top