The Twist is Not Enough: Why Paramount+ Needs More Subversive Storytelling

The thrill of being surprised by a plot twist is a universal experience for film fans, but it’s not enough to sustain interest in a story. Recent releases on Paramount+, such as “Strange Darling” and “Smile 2”, demonstrate that the streaming platform has a knack for crafting unexpected turns. However, this alone is not enough to elevate their storytelling.

Take “Strange Darling”, for instance. This 2024 thriller weaves together non-linear chapters, slowly revealing its complex plot through a maze of clues. The film’s unique structure and grainy aesthetic evoke the feeling of a 1970s fever dream. But its unpredictability raises questions about the story’s coherence, leaving viewers piecing together fragments of information by the end.

Effective narrative trickery can create suspense and surprise, but it ultimately relies on the viewer being invested in the characters’ journeys. “Strange Darling” suffers from a lack of character development, making it difficult for audiences to become emotionally attached to the protagonists. As a result, the twist feels more like a clever plot device than a genuine revelation.

Paramount+ would benefit from exploring more nuanced and character-driven storytelling. By investing in their characters’ emotional arcs, they can create narratives that are not just surprising but also meaningful. “Arrival” is a prime example of this approach. Director Denis Villeneuve’s 2016 sci-fi epic weaves together a complex narrative about communication and loss, deftly balancing intellectual curiosity with emotional resonance.

One of the most striking aspects of “Arrival” is its use of language as a metaphor for understanding. The film’s exploration of linguistics and cognitive science adds depth to the story, making it more than just a twisty plot device. By tackling complex themes in an accessible way, Villeneuve creates a narrative that lingers long after the credits roll.

In contrast, “Smile 2” takes a different approach. This sequel is an unapologetic maximalist exercise in excess, amping up the jump scares and neon-drenched visuals to chaotic effect. While it’s undeniably bold, the film’s twist feels more like a narrative gimmick than a genuine surprise.

A better model for Paramount+ can be found in “Shutter Island”, Martin Scorsese’s 2010 psychological thriller that masterfully builds tension through character study and atmospheric setting. The film’s twist is expertly crafted, but it’s the slow-burning suspense and eerie atmosphere that make it truly unforgettable. By investing in their characters’ emotional journeys and creating a richly detailed world, Paramount+ can craft stories that are not just surprising but also deeply resonant.

Ultimately, Paramount+ needs to move beyond relying on plot twists as a crutch for storytelling. By prioritizing character-driven narratives and nuanced themes, they can create content that truly engages audiences. This is not to say that surprise and subversion have no place in their storytelling – quite the opposite. But by pairing these elements with more substantial narrative structures, Paramount+ can craft stories that are both thrilling and meaningful.