When Garmin Watches Get It Right: A Plea to Apple for Map and Light Improvements

The impending launch of the Apple Watch Ultra 4 presents an opportunity for Apple to learn from its competitor, Garmin. As someone who has tested both Apple Watches and Garmin Fenix series extensively, I’m writing today as a long-time advocate for better integration between features.

Garmin’s new flagship watches, the Fenix 9 and Fenix 9 Pro, have made significant strides in sports tracking with their impressive array of features. Two features stand out: maps within activity screens and built-in flashlights. These are not novelties; they’re essential tools for navigating through long runs or hikes without phone coverage or providing extra light when running after sunset.

The current Apple Watch Ultra 3 offers some map functionality, but it’s severely limited. You can’t view your route in real-time within the Workout app; instead, you have to exit and switch screens, breaking the immersive experience Garmin offers. The Fenix series includes a simple yet effective solution: by scrolling down to your map screen, you can see your activity stats overlaid on top of the route, allowing for seamless navigation.

Garmin’s built-in flashlights are also notable. They’re useful in dark environments and an environmentally friendly alternative to carrying separate lights or using phone screens that drain battery life rapidly. The upgraded flashlight on the Fenix 9 Pro offers even more versatility with its new green light option and adjustable brightness levels.

It’s surprising Apple hasn’t followed suit yet, given their emphasis on integrating fitness features into their watches. One possible explanation is a focus on software-driven solutions – third-party apps like WorkOutDoors can replicate some of the map functionality on the Apple Watch. However, this approach lacks the seamless integration and intuitive design that Garmin’s built-in features provide.

While it might seem ambitious to hope for these features on the Apple Watch Ultra 4, I believe it’s a necessary step in closing the gap between Apple Watches and top-end Garmin devices. The tech industry often celebrates innovation by building upon existing ideas; in this case, it would be wise for Apple to take note of what works well elsewhere.

The implications are larger than just product development. As technology improves, users increasingly expect seamless integration across different platforms – the ease of navigation and lighting offered by Garmin’s watches is a significant departure from the fragmented experience on the Apple Watch Ultra 3. What does it mean for other manufacturers if one of the most prominent tech companies doesn’t keep pace with innovation?

Ultimately, the success of any new product hinges not only on its technical specifications but also how well it meets user needs. Borrowing ideas from Garmin could be a winning strategy – it would demonstrate Apple’s willingness to listen to feedback and ensure their watches remain competitive in an ever-evolving market.

The September launch event promises significant updates to the world of sports tracking, and I’m eagerly waiting to see if Apple will finally address these essential features. Whether they do or not, one thing is certain: as users, we deserve better than fragmented solutions that don’t quite meet our needs.